Nonprofit Law

Was a Gift to Win Women the Vote a Charity in 1867?

About this blog: Irving Steel is a law student, not a licensed attorney. Nothing on this site is legal advice. Reading this blog does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your specific situation, consult a licensed lawyer in your jurisdiction. This blog reflects personal views and is not affiliated with any law school, firm, or employer.

In plain terms

Charitable trust

A trust for a public purpose, such as relieving poverty or advancing education, that the law favors: it can last indefinitely and doesn't need named beneficiaries.

Francis Jackson, a Boston abolitionist, died in 1861 and left a will with three gifts to causes he supported. One paid to build public sentiment against slavery. One helped people who escaped slavery. The third left $5,000 to Wendell Phillips, Lucy Stone, and Susan B. Anthony, in trust “to secure the passage of laws granting women, whether married or unmarried, the right to vote; to hold office; to hold, manage, and devise property; and all other civil rights enjoyed by men.”

Jackson’s heirs argued that the gifts weren’t charities. A gift that failed would go back to the family. In Jackson v. Phillips, 96 Mass. (14 Allen) 539 (1867), the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts kept two of the gifts and struck one. Before you read on, guess which.

Why did the word “charity” matter so much?

Because charities get rules no private gift gets. The court put it plainly: “gifts to charitable uses are highly favored, and will be most liberally construed in order to accomplish the intent and purpose of the donor.” A private trust can’t tie up property past a fixed period, and the people it benefits have to be identifiable within that time. A charitable trust “may be perpetual in its duration,” and the trustees can choose who benefits.

So the label decided whether each gift lived. A gift that counted as charity could run for generations. A gift that didn’t was void, and the money went elsewhere.

What did the court decide?

The anti-slavery gift was a charity. Spreading books, newspapers, and lectures to move public opinion was, in the court’s words, “in either aspect, a lawful charity.” The fund for people who escaped slavery was a charity too. By the time the court ruled, the Thirteenth Amendment had ended slavery, so it redirected both funds to the closest purposes it could find, including the education and support of freed people. That redirection is the doctrine called cy pres.

The women’s rights gift was not. The court said it “cannot be sustained as a charity,” and explained why in two sentences:

“This bequest differs from the others in aiming directly and exclusively to change the laws; and its object cannot be accomplished without changing the Constitution also.”

The court added that whether such a change would be wise was a question it could not answer “sitting in a judicial capacity.” The gift failed.

Where did the court draw the line?

The line ran between persuading the public and changing the law. The court said the anti-slavery gift worked “not by legislation or political action, but by creating a public sentiment,” through “the usual means of public instruction, by books and newspapers, speeches and lectures.” That made it education. The women’s rights gift aimed “directly and exclusively to change the laws,” and in 1867 the court would not call that a charitable purpose, whatever the cause’s merits.

The two gifts did not differ in method as much as that suggests. Jackson’s women’s rights gift also paid for “the preparation and circulation of books, the delivery of lectures.” What the court weighed was the goal the will named first: getting laws passed.

What does the case leave us with?

The case is a snapshot of one court in 1867, not a statement of today’s law. Charity law has changed a great deal since. What hasn’t changed is the lesson for anyone drafting a gift: how a court labels the purpose can decide whether the gift survives at all.

Related: Cy Pres: What Happens to a Charitable Gift When Its Purpose Dies covers what the court did with the gifts it kept. More nonprofit law posts are collected in Nonprofit Law, Plainly.

I am a law student, not a lawyer. Nothing here is legal advice.

Irving Steel

Irving Steel

Irving Steel is a second-year law student at Roger Williams University School of Law. In summer 2026 he was a legal intern in the Non-Profit Organizations / Public Charities Division of the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office. Before law school he founded an environmental nonprofit in Shanghai, co-founded the media company 668 KTV, and earned a Master of Public Health. He writes in plain language about how the law works and who it affects.

Hiring for summer 2027? See my experience and selected writing, or get in touch.